Skip to content Accessibility info

Our Blog

RightSure Insurance Group

Insurance Considerations for Arizona's Historical Homes

Arizona's rich history is reflected in its diverse array of historical homes, ranging from Spanish Colonial Revival and Territorial-style residences to Victorian-era mansions and adobe dwellings. Owning a historical home is a unique privilege, but it also comes with specific challenges and considerations when it comes to insurance coverage. In this guide, we'll explore the insurance considerations that owners of historical homes in Arizona should be aware of to protect their valuable properties against risks, preserve their architectural heritage, and ensure financial security.

  1. Understanding Historical Homes:
    Historical homes are not just architectural structures; they are living artifacts that embody the cultural, social, and architectural heritage of a bygone era. These homes often feature unique design elements, craftsmanship, and historical significance that contribute to their charm and appeal. However, the age, construction materials, and architectural features of historical homes can pose challenges for insurance coverage and restoration efforts.
  • Architectural Styles: Historical homes in Arizona exhibit a diverse range of architectural styles influenced by the region's cultural heritage, including Spanish Colonial, Mission Revival, Pueblo Revival, Territorial, Craftsman, Victorian, and Mid-Century Modern. Each architectural style has its own distinctive features, materials, and construction techniques that contribute to the home's historical character and value.
  • Preservation Challenges: Preserving and maintaining historical homes requires careful attention to detail, adherence to preservation standards, and compliance with local historic preservation ordinances. Owners of historical homes face challenges such as aging infrastructure, deteriorating building materials, code compliance issues, and finding skilled craftsmen capable of performing restoration work using traditional methods and materials.
  • Cultural Significance: Historical homes often have cultural significance and may be listed on local, state, or national historic registers, designations, or landmarks. These designations recognize the historical, architectural, or cultural significance of the property and may impose restrictions or requirements regarding alterations, renovations, or demolitions to preserve its integrity and authenticity.
  1. Insurance Considerations for Historical Homes:
    Insuring a historical home requires specialized coverage tailored to the unique risks and characteristics of these properties. Historical homes may face higher replacement costs, restoration expenses, and liability exposures compared to newer homes, necessitating comprehensive insurance coverage and risk management strategies.
  • Replacement Cost vs. Market Value: Historical homes may have a higher replacement cost than their market value due to the unique architectural features, custom craftsmanship, and historical significance. Owners should ensure their insurance coverage reflects the full replacement cost of the home and its contents to adequately cover restoration expenses in the event of damage or loss.
  • Historic Replacement Materials: Insurers should consider the use of historic replacement materials and craftsmanship techniques when assessing the replacement cost of historical homes. Rebuilding or restoring a historical home may require sourcing period-appropriate materials, skilled artisans, and specialized tradespeople familiar with historical restoration practices.
  • Ordinance and Law Coverage: Historical homes may be subject to local building codes, zoning regulations, and historic preservation ordinances that dictate specific requirements for renovations, repairs, or alterations. Owners should consider purchasing ordinance and law coverage to cover the additional expenses of bringing the home into compliance with current building codes or historic preservation standards following a covered loss.
  • Specialized Coverage Options: Insurers offer specialized insurance products and endorsements tailored to historical homes, such as Historic Homeowners Insurance, Historic Property Insurance, or Guaranteed Replacement Cost coverage. These policies may provide coverage for unique risks, such as restoration costs, code upgrades, architectural salvage, and archaeological excavation.
  • Valuation and Appraisal: Owners of historical homes should obtain professional valuations and appraisals to assess the replacement cost, market value, and historical significance of the property. Appraisals conducted by qualified appraisers familiar with historical properties can provide an accurate assessment of the home's value and help determine appropriate insurance coverage limits.
  • Preservation Easements: Some owners of historical homes may choose to place preservation easements on their properties to protect their historical integrity and prevent inappropriate alterations or demolitions. Preservation easements may entitle owners to tax benefits or incentives and may influence insurance considerations, as insurers may require additional documentation or coverage endorsements for properties subject to preservation easements.
  1. Risk Mitigation and Loss Prevention:
    In addition to obtaining comprehensive insurance coverage, owners of historical homes can take proactive measures to mitigate risks, prevent losses, and preserve the integrity of their properties:
  • Routine Maintenance: Implement a regular maintenance schedule to address issues such as roofing, siding, painting, plumbing, electrical systems, and structural integrity. Proper maintenance can help prevent deterioration, minimize damage, and extend the lifespan of historical homes.
  • Disaster Preparedness: Develop a disaster preparedness plan and emergency response procedures to protect historical homes from natural disasters, such as wildfires, floods, earthquakes, hurricanes, and severe storms. Install preventive measures such as fire suppression systems, lightning protection, and flood barriers to mitigate risks and minimize damage.
  • Security Measures: Install security systems, surveillance cameras, alarm systems, and motion sensors to deter vandalism, theft, and unauthorized access to historical properties. Secure doors, windows, and entry points to prevent intrusions and protect valuable belongings, artwork, and historical artifacts.
  • Documentation and Inventory: Maintain detailed records, documentation, and inventories of historical homes, including photographs, architectural drawings, historical documents, restoration records, and receipts for renovations or repairs. Documenting the home's history, provenance, and architectural features can facilitate insurance claims processing and restoration efforts in the event of damage or loss.
  • Heritage Conservation: Engage with local historical societies, preservation organizations, and heritage conservation groups to support efforts to preserve, protect, and promote Arizona's historical homes and cultural heritage. Participate in educational programs, heritage tours, and community events to raise awareness of the value of historical preservation and stewardship.

Owning a historical home in Arizona is a unique opportunity to preserve the state's rich architectural heritage and cultural legacy. By understanding the insurance considerations, risks, and preservation challenges associated with historical homes, owners can safeguard their valuable properties, ensure financial protection, and contribute to the preservation of Arizona's historical legacy for future generations to enjoy.